Despite Rising Trends, Cloud-based ERPs are not for Everyone
- alvis10
- Jan 24
- 6 min read
Updated: Feb 3
What You Need To Know About ERP Deployment
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems have evolved significantly since their inception in the 1970s. Initially, ERPs were primarily on-premise solutions, requiring businesses to purchase and maintain their own hardware and software.
In recent years, cloud-based ERP systems have surged in popularity, addressing several pain points associated with traditional on-premise solutions. Key drivers of cloud ERPs include the elimination of the need for on-site hardware, significantly reducing IT costs and simplifying implementation processes.
Despite these benefits, many successful companies still rely on on-premise ERP, particularly those with complex IT infrastructures. While cloud-based ERPs are gaining traction, each deployment option has its own strengths and weaknesses and may not be suitable for everyone - at least not yet.
This article compares the strengths and weaknesses of both on-premise and cloud-based ERPs in terms of customization, scalability, and cost, helping you make an informed decision that best suits your organization’s unique needs. It also provides recommendations on the best ERP for both deployment options.
Customization and Flexibility (On-Premise wins)
Customization is a key reason why many companies have not transitioned to cloud ERPs. On-premise ERP systems offer a higher degree of customization, enabling organizations to tailor the software to their specific needs. This includes deeper integration with existing systems and the ability to modify the underlying code for maximum control. These capabilities are invaluable for businesses with unique requirements, complex operations, or strict regulatory compliance needs as data is stored locally.
In contrast, cloud ERPs provide less control since they are managed by the ERP provider. They typically offer pre-configured modules and settings with limited customization options and specific APIs or integration. While this limits customization, preconfigured templates offer significant benefits, including faster implementation, reduced deployment effort, consistent user experiences, and a lower risk of errors.
Overall, cloud ERPs may not be ideal for highly specific or complex requirements, making on-premise ERPs a better choice for organizations seeking extensive customization.
Scalability (Cloud wins)
Scalability is a crucial factor when selecting an ERP system, referring to its ability to adapt and grow with an organization’s changing needs. Let’s compare the two deployment options in terms of horizontal and vertical scalability.
Cloud-based ERPs are inherently scalable, allowing organizations to adjust computing resources as needed. Cloud providers can dynamically allocate additional resources to handle increased users or transactions without significant performance degradation.
Additionally, cloud-based ERPs support vertical scaling by accommodating more complex business processes and data volumes through advanced features offered by providers. Scaling on-premise ERP systems, on the other hand, often requires significant infrastructure upgrades, such as new hardware or software components. This can be costly and time-consuming.
While on-premise systems can be scaled horizontally by adding hardware resources, the process remains more complex and expensive compared to cloud-based ERPs.
In general, cloud-based ERPs offer superior scalability, enabling organizations to quickly adapt to changing business conditions without the complexities of on-premise systems.
Costs & Management (Cloud Wins)
On-premise ERP requires substantial upfront investments in servers, storage, networking equipment, and IT infrastructure. Once implemented, ongoing costs for updates, patches, and security fixes are necessary to keep the system operational and secure. A dedicated IT team is also required to oversee the system, troubleshoot issues, and provide support. In contrast, cloud-based ERPs provide a more cost-effective solution by eliminating many of these expenses. Cloud providers manage the infrastructure, including servers, storage, and network components, while handling software updates and security patches to ensure the system remains up-to-date and secure.
By outsourcing these responsibilities, organizations can focus on their core business activities, leading to improved efficiency, reduced operational costs, and faster time-to-market. Additionally, cloud-based ERPs offer flexible pricing models, such as subscription-based fees, for predictable and scalable costs.
Security & Compliance (On-Premise Wins)
Cloud-based ERP comes with robust security measures, as providers invest heavily in security teams and infrastructure. Regular software updates and secure data centers help protect customer data. However, some companies may prefer greater control over their data and security infrastructure, making on-premise ERPs a better option. Compliance is another critical consideration. With cloud-based ERPs, data storage locations must align with regulations such as GDPR or CCPA. Organizations must ensure compliance with local data privacy laws, which may pose challenges if cloud providers operate in different regulatory environments.
On-premise ERP solutions provide organizations with complete control over data security and compliance measures, making them a preferred choice for industries with stringent regulatory requirements.
The Verdict
Choosing between cloud-based and on-premise ERP depends on your organization's IT capabilities, customization needs, resources, complexity, security requirements, and risk tolerance.
Consider on-premise ERP if your organization:
1. Requires high customization levels
2. Must comply with strict regulatory requirements
3. Has a significant existing IT infrastructure
4. Can afford a larger upfront investment Consider cloud-based ERP if your organization:
1. Prioritizes cost-effectiveness and scalability
2. Requires rapid deployment and access to the latest innovations
3. Has limited IT resources or expertise
4. Is comfortable with outsourcing infrastructure management
The Best ERP for both On-premise and Cloud
Regardless of your deployment choice, SAP S/4HANA stands out as an ideal ERP solution. It offers a comprehensive suite of features designed to streamline operations and drive efficiency in both on-premise and cloud environments.
Faster Processing Times
One of the key differentiators of SAP S/4HANA is its use of an in-memory database. Unlike traditional disk-based databases, which store data on physical disks, SAP S/4 HANA stores data in the computer's main memory (RAM). This significantly reduces query response times, improving overall system performance. More specifically, you can access real-time analytics, even when processing large amounts of data, enabling you to make data-driven decisions more quickly.
Moreover, SAP S/4 HANA’s architecture simplifies data modeling, reducing data redundancy and enhancing data quality and consistency.
Intelligent AI Features
As amazing as new technologies and features sound, their effectiveness is minimal if users find them hard to navigate and utilize. That’s why SAP S/4HANA includes Copilot, an AI-powered assistant designed to simplify the use of the ERP system and provide valuable insights for maximum efficiency and competitiveness. SAP S/4HANA's other intelligent features, powered by machine learning and artificial intelligence, allow you to automate processes, predict outcomes, and optimize solutions.
While this wide array of AI implementations is impressive, what makes it truly shine is its comprehensiveness and relevance, providing intelligent solutions for any industry your company operates.
Industry-Specific Solutions
The range and depth of features offered by SAP S/4 HANA are unmatched - extending across industries such as manufacturing, retail, healthcare, finance, HR, and more.
These features are tailored to meet the unique needs of various sectors, including best practice solutions, pre-configured workflows, and industry-specific functionality to help organizations optimize their operations and achieve their goals. With its ability to handle high transaction volumes, adapt to specific business processes, integrate seamlessly with other tools, and provide real-time analytics, SAP S/4HANA empowers organizations to make meaningful, data-driven decisions and excel at what they do best. SAP S/4HANA is undoubtedly a valuable investment for organizations, thanks to its comprehensive features, scalability, customization options, analytics, industry-specific solutions, and integration capabilities.
What are SAP S/4 HANA users saying?
Ready to unlock the full potential of your growing business?
Discover how SAP S/4HANA can streamline your operations, enhance efficiency, and drive sustainable growth.
Who is ABeam Consulting?
ABeam Consulting, a global leader in management and IT consulting, is a wholly owned subsidiary of NEC Corporation. Headquartered in Tokyo, Japan, ABeam Consulting delivers measurable value through a client-first approach, seamlessly integrating industry expertise with advanced technologies.
Driven by a vision to be Asia’s top consulting firm, ABeam Consulting empowers organizations with its 8,300-strong workforce and a robust global network of alliance partners. Our end-to-end solutions drive transformation at every level, ensuring sustained success.
ABeam Consulting stands as a catalyst for change, collaborating with organizations to co-create a sustainable future and tackle complex challenges. ABeam Consulting Singapore’s strategic partnership with SAP enables us to offer comprehensive SAP solutions, including implementation, consulting, and support services.
For over 40 years, ABeam Consulting has led business transformation across industries, delivering strategic planning, operational excellence, and cutting-edge digital solutions. In an era of uncertainty, we empower organizations to transcend conventional frameworks and create new value.
As the global landscape evolves with disruptions like the pandemic, geopolitical shifts, and climate change, ABeam Consulting remains a trusted Real Partner for transformation. We design holistic strategies and collaborate with stakeholders to drive sustainable growth and build a resilient future.